5951 Milford Road, East Stroudsburg, PA 18302 (MLS# PM-144455)

Listing Service: Full Service

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

List Price: $750,000

Current Price: $750,000

Status: Active

Listing Contract Date: 2026-09-03

Parcel Number: 09.4.1.73-1

Municipality: Middle Smithfield Township

High School District: East Stroudsburg Area

County Tax Amount: 3379.38

Municipal Tax Amount: 1079.72

School Tax Amount: 19539.76

Tax Other Annual Assessment Amount: 669.99

Tax Annual Amount: 23731

Tax Assessed Value: 616980

Tax Year: 2025

Tax Map Number: 09734404615034

Tax Book Number: 2594

Tax Page Number: 4239

Deed Recording Date: 2021-11-19

Zoning Description: Commercial

Rooms Total: 4

Bathrooms Half: 1

Above Grade Finished Area: 1965

Below Grade Finished Area: 875

Living Area: 2840

Living Area Source: Estimated

Above Grade Unfinished Area: 0

Below Grade Unfinished Area: 0

Building Area Source: Estimated

Stories: 2

Year Built Source: Public Records

Fireplace YN: Yes

Pool Private YN: Yes

Garage YN: No

Carport YN: No

Open Parking YN: No

Lot Size Acres: 5.12

Association YN: No

Water Body Access YN: No

List Price/SqFt: 264.08

Bedrooms Total: 4

Bathrooms Total: 3

Bathrooms Full: 2

Building Area Total: 2840

Year Built: 1945

Furnished: Unfurnished

Public Remarks: $150K+ INCOME-PRODUCING RETREAT -- INDOOR POOL, 5 ACRES, COMMERCIAL ZONING Rare investor opportunity: a proven, turnkey short-term rental generating $150,000+ in annual rental income, set on 5 private acres with commercial zoning -- offering flexibility to continue STR operations, expand, or explore alternative commercial uses. This 1941 stone cabin has been reimagined into a 4-bed, 2.5-bath compound, anchored by a separate indoor heated pool, open year-round with a 120'' projector screen -- a rare amenity that drives premium rates and repeat bookings. Inside, soaring ceilings with warm wood accents create an elevated main living area, complemented by an updated kitchen and several bonus spaces, including a game room with pool table and darts. A separate private suite with its own entrance, bedroom, bath, and kitchen adds flexible income configurations. Nestled into the hillside for privacy, the backyard is a private oasis featuring a tent setup and firepit, plus ample acreage with room for further expansion. Located minutes from Shawnee Mountain, Bushkill Falls, zip-lining, and the area's top Pocono attractions, this property captures consistent demand from the region's thriving tourism economy. Highlights: $150K+ documented rental income Separate indoor heated pool, year-round 5 acres, commercial zoning -- expansion potential Soaring wood-accented ceilings Updated kitchen Bonus spaces incl. game room Private suite -- separate entrance Hillside privacy, expansive outdoor living Backyard oasis: tent, firepit, room to expand A rare combination of proven cash flow and long-term optionality.

Standard: 1

Cash: 1

Conventional: 1

FHA: 1

Close Of Escrow: 1

No Common Walls: 1

House: 1

Residential: 1

Colonial: 1

Ceiling Fan(s): 1

Fireplaces Total: 1

Electric: 1

Baseboard: 1

Hot Water: 1

Electric: 1

Natural Gas: 1

Oil: 1

Well: 1

On Site Septic: 1

Natural Gas Available: 1

Driveway: 1

Living Room: 1

Bathroom 2: 1

Bathroom 2 Level: First

Living Room Level: Second

Dining Room: 1

Bedroom 2: 1

Bedroom 2 Level: First

Bedroom 3: 1

Bedroom 3 Level: Second

Dining Room Level: Second

Kitchen: 1

Kitchen Level: First

Other: 1

Other Level: First

Primary Bathroom: 1

Primary Bathroom Level: Third

Primary Bedroom: 1

Primary Bedroom Level: Third

County: Monroe

Street Number: 5951

Street Name: Milford

Street Suffix: Road

City (Post Office): East Stroudsburg

State: PA

Postal Code: 18302

Subdivision Name: None